Host Antje Utgaard poses with the cast of Miss/Match Season Five

Miss/Match Season Five Recap

By OFTV Editor

May 8, 2025

9 Minute Read

OFTV’s Miss/Match is back, and Season Five is turning up the heat! Host Antje Utgaard returns to play cupid with your favorite OnlyFans creators. With new challenges, flirty games, and no more blindfolds, these singles are in for a thrilling ride. Who will find love, and who will crash and burn? Read on for our exclusive recap of Miss/Match Season Five and catch every episode free on OFTV!

Warning: spoilers ahead.

S5E1: Marco DelVecchio / Lauren Summer

Season Five kicks off with Lauren Summer and Marco DelVecchio. Lauren, a model and influencer, is looking for a witty guy who can keep up with her banter. Marco, a comedian and podcaster, is ready to meet the girl of his dreams. 

Unlike past seasons of Miss/Match, there are no blindfolds, so they dive into conversation right away. They bond over life in LA and their shared struggle with IBS. 

Antje introduces the game Lie to Me, and sparks fly—though Marco’s not sure about Lauren’s hairless cat.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Lauren, “I’m from Orlando, Florida.” Marco, “Oh very cool. The windy city.”

Next up, Antje leads Lauren and Marco into a round of Down In The DMs. Both are social media pros, eager to flaunt their digital flirting skills, though Marco wonders if some of Lauren’s messages only land because she’s hot. 

The game has them all laughing, and Marco is impressed by Lauren’s ability to poke fun at herself. But while they’re having a blast, can they turn the fun into something real?

 Now, they’re gearing up for their Deeper Dive, a chance to see if their connection runs deeper.

After slipping into swimsuits, Marco raises a glass and jokingly toasts to their future kids. He and Lauren discuss past relationships and family life. 

Marco admits he often lands in the friend zone, while Lauren wants to date someone she could genuinely be friends with. They both sense a spark and see real potential. 

The moment of truth arrives—Marco worries their chemistry is more friendly than romantic, but Lauren hopes for more. It’s a match! Here’s to many more laugh-filled dates!

Miss/Match Season Five Recap Gif: Lauren flips her paddle, Antje, “I knew it!” Marco, “I was scared.”

It's a MATCH!

S5E2: Zach Clayton / Ashley Serrano

Ashley Serrano, a bikini model from Miami, is looking for commitment, while social media star Zach Clayton wants someone who can match his spontaneous energy. Ashley’s ideal man is tall, but could Zach be the short king she never knew she needed? 

Though Zach isn’t her type, there's an instant spark when they lock eyes. Some initial awkwardness arises, and Zach worries about Ashley’s partying habits. 

During the Observation Game, both prove they’ve been paying attention. Zach hopes a real connection could still bloom.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Zach, “She had 2 rings. Both hands. Bracelet on. Anklet on. Chain on. I be paying attention.”
Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Antje, “Aim for that extra spicy hole.”

Riding the vibes from the first part of their date, Jason and Courtney must build furniture together while handcuffed to each other and without any instructions.

The challenge showcases Jason's positivity and Courtney's willingness to let him take the lead, but sadly, not their furniture-making skills. The ‘chair’ they made was questionable, but their chemistry was undeniable, with both laughing at their efforts and enjoying the process.

As they head to the hot tub, Courtney and Jason reflect on how comfortable they feel with each other.

During the Deeper Dive, Courtney and Jason discover shared family values and eerily similar thought patterns. However, red flags emerge for Courtney when Jason reveals his recent breakup and his unwillingness to move for love, especially because she is a hopeless romantic.

Despite this, their connection feels effortless and familiar. They discuss communication styles and realize their values are perfectly aligned.

At the reveal... it’s a ‘Match!’ They playfully plan a cooking date for their next encounter, leaving viewers eager to see if this instant connection will sizzle or fizzle.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Ashley, “I want 4 to 6 kids.” Linger on Zach’s reaction.

It's a MISS!

S5E3: Justin Assad / Dainty Wilder 

Surviving Paradise and Perfect Match alum Justin Assad knows the dating show game well. He’s after the perfect mix of looks and personality, minus the small talk. Australian model Dainty Wilder wants an animal lover open to long distance. 

Though not each other’s usual type, their conversation flows, despite Justin’s aversion to Australia. Dainty worries he’s too confident. 

During the Observation Game, Dainty recalls details effortlessly, while Justin falls short. Still, they laugh, proving chemistry is more than winning.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Lauren, “I’m from Orlando, Florida.” Marco, “Oh very cool. The windy city.”
Miss/Match Season Five Recap Gif: Justin pulls a piece of wood, tower falls, linger on Antje’s reaction.

Next, Antje introduces Wood You Rather—a Jenga-style game with spicy questions. Justin and Dainty share their dating preferences, both wanting to spend lots of time with their partners and dive into love headfirst. 

They bond over being homebodies who enjoy cozy nights in. After Justin makes a bold move and the tower collapses, he expresses how happy he is that they’re both low-maintenance and appreciate life’s little things. 

Dainty agrees, and Antje tells them to get ready for the hot tub.

During their Deeper Dive, Dainty quickly asks Justin about his dating history. She’s uneasy about the short length of his past relationships but appreciates his support for her career. 

Both want a lifelong partner, but when Dainty shares her love for birds, Justin tells a white lie, pretending to agree. After their hot tub chat, it’s decision time. 

Dainty reveals first—it’s a miss. A bummer for Justin, who had chosen to match. Maybe next time, they’ll look for love on the same continent.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Dainty reveals MISS paddle, Justin reaction.

Dainty: MISS

Justin: MATCH

S5E4: Alfredo Sanchez-Ortiz / Jacky Romero 

Content creator Alfredo Sanchez-Ortiz is a ball of energy seeking a strong, resilient woman. Reggaeton artist Jacky Romero, aka Jacky June, wants a man who matches her ambition. 

Their instant attraction grows as they bond over their Hispanic heritage, spirituality, and good luck charms. Jacky admires Alfredo’s perseverance. 

During Lie to Me, they laugh while spotting each other’s mistruths, and Alfredo finds Jacky “caliente.” Both seem optimistic about what’s next for this date.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Alfredo, “Caliente.”
Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Alfredo and Jacky’s reactions to their caricature portrait

Next up is Pictures of You, where Jacky and Alfredo describe each other to a caricature artist while continuing to connect. Alfredo calls Jacky the “Latin Kim Kardashian,” and she dubs him the “Puerto Rican Brad Pitt.” 

Jacky’s impressed that Alfredo noticed the honey in her eyes but struggles to recall his physical details, focusing more on his personality. 

Although their portrait isn’t a perfect likeness, the game deepens their bond. Heading into the Deeper Dive, Alfredo is excited, but Jacky feels nervous.

In the hot tub, Alfredo asks Jacky what she’s looking for romantically. She’s focused on her career but open to love.

Alfredo, on the other hand, hopes to find romance naturally without pressure. He’s confident he can handle a driven woman, but Jacky worries he’s saying the right things to win her over. 

The moment of truth arrives—and it’s a match! Their shared ambition and spiritual connection bring them together, and for their second date, they’re off for sushi!

Miss/Match Season Five recap gif: Antje, “It’s a match!”

It's a MATCH!

S5E5: Alec Maternowski / Brennah Black

Model and lingerie designer Brennah Black is a hopeless romantic seeking a confident man who supports her dreams. Alec Maternowski, a nurse-turned-influencer, wants an ambitious, open-minded woman who loves the gym. 

Alec is immediately drawn to Brennah, but she worries he’s too much of a pretty boy. He admires her career, and she’s surprised by his medical background. 

During the Observation Game, Alec struggles to recall details, while Brennah proves far more attentive, leaving her wondering what Alec was focused on.

Miss/Match Season Five recap gif: Antje “Yes! Extra spicy hole.”

As Hot Takes begins, Brennah wonders if Alec is indifferent to her, but he insists he’s eager to know her better. 

They bond over shared dislikes for fast food and similar home habits but differ on topics like body count and letting dogs sleep in bed. Alec admires Brennah’s chill, understanding nature, while she calls him a “typical man”—a compliment, she assures. 

After the game, both realize there’s more to uncover before deciding if they’re truly a match.

Next up is their Deeper Dive. They start with a shared belief in aliens before discussing their dating preferences. 

As they talk, they realize they have a lot in common—especially their desire to marry and start a family. Alec wonders if Brennah feels the connection, but it’s decision time. 

Brennah reveals first—it’s a match! But when Alec flips his paddle, it’s a miss. His concern over her career-driven nature held him back, but Brennah wasn’t looking for a man intimidated by her ambition anyway.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Antje “Are you kidding me? Look at her.” show Brennah. Alec, “I know.”

Brennah: MATCH

Alec: MISS

S5E6: Georgio Poullas / Madison Q 

Madison Q, a cosplay creator and aspiring veterinarian, wants someone in the industry who just “gets it.” Georgio Poullas, a wrestling content creator, is looking for a wholesome woman to meet his family. 

They bond over their OnlyFans experiences, and Georgio is amazed when Madison shares she's in vet school in Scotland. Their shared love for animals deepens their connection. 

In Lie to Me, Georgio is shocked Madison hasn’t dated in two years, while she’s surprised he’s never left the country.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Georgio, “What the hell is Klingon?”
Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Reveal of portrait, reaction, Georgio, “That’s the worst I’ve ever looked.”

During Pictures of You, Madison and Georgio test their memory of each other’s features. Madison admires Georgio’s kind eyes, and he feels the same way. 

Though they miss a few details, their connection is clear—they’ve been focused more on their minds than looks. Still, Georgio can’t resist mentioning Madison’s “kissable” lips. 

When their portrait is revealed, Georgio jokes it’s the worst he’s ever looked, but they share a laugh over it.

In their Deeper Dive, Ashlynn shares her love for adventure, which Isaac appreciates. However, when Isaac reveals he’s a DJ, she worries he might be too much of a partier.

They bond over their shared loyalty and impatience, but a red flag is raised when Ashlynn learns that Isaac has only been in one relationship.

After contemplating their decisions, it’s time for the reveal. While Isaac is confident, Ashlynn is less sure, but in the end, it’s a ‘Match!’ The two plan a picnic date in Hawaii.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Madison reveals miss paddle. Georgio, “Wow.

Georgio: MATCH

Madison: MISS

S5E7: Uncle Lazer / Casey Boonstra

Uncle Lazer, a touring comedian, has struggled to find love. Could OFTV In Real Life host Casey Boonstra be the one? After all, she says she’s ready for someone to ignite her passion. 

Though Lazer isn’t Casey’s usual type, she’s impressed by his “immaculate” mullet, and he’s captivated by her beauty, calling her “the cure for cancer.” 

After a lively first chat, Antje challenges them to Lie to Me, revealing unexpected sides of Lazer that spark Casey’s curiosity.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Lazer, “Can’t wait to meet my future ex-wife.” sticks out tongue.
Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Casey, “I’m so bad at flirting.”

Next up is Down in the DMs, where Casey and Lazer test their flirting skills using emojis. Their choices baffle each other but lead to plenty of laughs.

Casey admits she’s not the best at flirting, while Lazer takes a bolder approach. Antje urges them both to step up their game if they want to impress anyone.

After the game, Lazer is eager to learn more about Casey’s life and backstory, while Casey wants to see who Lazer is when he’s not cracking jokes.

In the hot tub for Deeper Dive, Casey peels back Lazer’s layers. When he asks why she hasn’t settled down, he’s impressed by her ambition. 

Casey teaches him Aussie slang, and Lazer shares stories from life on the road. She admires his outlook and is surprised by his depth. 

When it’s decision time, Antje is shocked—it’s a miss for both! Lazer feels Casey is too busy for a relationship, while she hopes to catch one of his shows.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Lazer shrugging while holding “miss” sign.

It's a MISS!

S5E8: Chris Hahn / Claire Northfield

You may recognize Chris Hahn from Dated and Related or Perfect Match, but he’s hoping Miss/Match is his lucky charm in love. Claire Northfield, a pilot who’s never been in love, is open to making a connection. 

Upon meeting, they bond over their New Jersey roots and German heritage. Claire laughs when she realizes she’s taller than Chris, while Chris worries about their nine-year age gap. 

Antje challenges them to the Observation Game. Though they struggle with physical details, they excel at recalling their conversation.

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Chris, “You’re taller than me!” Linger on Claire’s reaction.
Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Antje rolling her eyes.

With easy conversation flowing, Chris and Claire head outside for Wood You Rather. They explore each other’s preferences in relationships and the bedroom, tackling some lighthearted questions. 

Claire shares her passions for flying and riding motorcycles, impressing Chris. They both agree they want a partner who isn’t glued to their phone. 

After the game, they reflect on how much they’ve learned about each other—everything piquing their interest. However, Claire isn’t sure she sees a romantic future with Chris.

In the hot tub, Claire shares her travel adventures, and Chris loves her spontaneity. He’s excited to learn she enjoys surfing, one of his passions. As Claire talks about becoming a pilot, Chris calls her a “badass.” 

They discuss the challenge of distance—neither wants a long-distance relationship, but they’re open to enjoying the moment. Antje must interrupt their flow and force them to make a decision. 

When Claire and Chris turn their paddles… it’s a match! A perfect way to end Season Five on a high note—thanks for tuning in!

Miss/Match Season Five Recap gif: Chris & Claire, “It’s a match!”

It's a MATCH!

Find your new favorite show on OFTV.

Loved Miss/Match Season Five? Check out Season Four!

Related Posts