Making new friends can be hard to do when you’re a busy adult. That’s why we asked host Antje Utgaard to come aboard our newest OFTV creation: Miss/Match. Part reality show, part social experiment, Miss/Match brings together two very different OnlyFans creators each week for an afternoon of icebreakers, physical challenges, and some deep conversations. After spending hours in the hot seat, these perfect strangers have to decide whether they’re a miss, a match, or maybe even something more.
No two episodes of Miss/Match are the same. Some pairs hit it off instantly. Some pairs need a couple of Antje’s challenges before they warm up to each other. Some pairs may be perfectly happy never speaking to each other again. Each episode is full of fun, adventure, and plenty of surprises!
Warning: spoilers ahead.
E1: Amber Diamond / THMPSN
Miss/Match kicks off with confident TV personality Amber Diamond and Australian musician THMPSN. They hit it off immediately, with Amber completely unfazed by his collection of over 100 snakes.
During the Icebreakers, Antje quizzes them on details about each other. Despite just meeting, they recall surprisingly specific answers.
Early on, their connection feels easy and natural.
The Physical Challenge puts their teamwork to the test in an escape room. Amber takes the lead, while THMPSN stays supportive. They finish with time to spare, building even more confidence in their dynamic. In the Deeper Dive, they head to the hot tub and open up about their goals and relationships. They find they’re largely on the same page.
At the final reveal, they must decide if they’re a Miss, a Match, or something more. THMPSN goes all in right away. Amber hesitates, but ultimately agrees. They choose Something More.
It’s SOMETHING MORE!
E2: Chase DeMoor / Mikey
Charming comedian and vlogger Mikey Estrella meets Too Hot to Handle star Chase DeMoor, and Mikey’s nerves disappear as soon as Chase walks in.
In the Icebreakers round, Antje quizzes them on details about each other. Some answers catch them off guard, and Mikey’s playful jab at Chase’s style doesn’t quite land.
Despite a rocky Icebreakers round, their flirtatious energy seems to be winning out.
For the Physical Challenge, they take on a blindfolded obstacle course. Chase guides Mikey through first, but struggles to follow directions when they switch roles. They make it to the finish line, but not without a few missteps along the way.
In the Deeper Dive, they settle into a more serious conversation, opening up about past relationships and family.
At the final reveal, they must decide if they’re a Miss or a Match. Mikey chooses Match, but Chase doesn’t feel the same way.
Mikey: MATCH
Chase: MISS
E3: Peter Vigilante
Soft-spoken introvert Caylee meets emotional Italian sweetheart Peter Vigilante, and their shared shyness makes for a slow start.
Peter earns brownie points by admitting he cries at movies, and they quickly bond over both being Italian.
The Icebreakers go better than expected, even if the memory portion trips them up. The connection builds gradually, but it’s clearly there.
Their Physical Challenge, pitching a tent while handcuffed together, throws them completely off. They struggle through it, and at one point even need Antje to step in, but they manage to laugh along the way. In the Deeper Dive, they open up about growth, relationships, and what they want moving forward.
At the reveal, Caylee admits her first impressions were off and chooses Match. Peter goes a step further and chooses Something More.
Caylee: MATCH
Peter: MORE
E4: Sumner Stroh / Kristian
When Texas model and content creator Sumner Stroh meets self-described serial reality show dater Kristian Barbarich, the vibe is genuinely awkward at first.
But once the Icebreakers get going, they lock in. They dominate both rounds, nearly sweeping the challenges, and their recall is so strong that Antje throws in a bonus question to trip them up. It doesn’t work.
What starts off awkward quickly turns into real interest.
They carry that momentum into the Physical Challenge, an escape room that they finish efficiently through strong communication. Sumner begins to open up, warming to Kristian’s energy.
In the Deeper Dive, things click even more as they realize how closely they align on values, family, and long-term goals.
At the reveal, neither hesitates. Both choose Match.
It’s a MATCH!
E5: Miss Lexi / Eric Guilmette
Self-described “New Age hippie” Eric Guilmette meets fellow model Miss Lexi, and the attraction is immediate. Their chemistry is playful, flirty, and easy from the start.
Both brainy athletes, they breeze through most of the Icebreakers. The memory challenge trips them up a bit, but they hold onto the connection. Now, the chemistry is feeling balanced and very real.
Eric’s patience and steady communication stand out during the blindfolded obstacle course, even as Lexi struggles to guide him. They manage to complete the challenge with solid teamwork and time to spare.
In the Deeper Dive, they bond over fitness, meditation, and eerily similar beliefs about soulmates.
At the reveal, Eric leans toward Something More, while Lexi chooses Match.
Lexi: MATCH
Eric: MORE
E6: Paige Woolen / Jay Gould
LA influencer Paige Woolen meets laid-back Midwesterner Jay Gould, and the mutual attraction is immediate. A shared love of dogs helps things along, even if Paige isn’t sold on Jay’s cow-print shorts.
Their flirty, slightly chaotic energy carries through the Icebreakers, where Antje’s anatomy-themed questions only add to the unpredictability.
Jay’s rugged Midwestern side shows up during the Physical Challenge as they pitch a tent while handcuffed together. Paige cheers him on, and their teamwork helps them finish with time to spare.
In the Deeper Dive, the tone shifts when Jay’s approach to tipping food delivery drivers raises some red flags for Paige.
At the reveal, Jay initially leans toward something more before ultimately choosing Match, alongside Paige.
It’s a MATCH!
Read more Miss/Match recaps.
